trešdiena, 2008. gada 26. novembris

Why there are so few Asimov's movies?

After I had read Asimovs Robot, Empire and Foundation series I started to search for movies. I'm sorry to say, that after serious googling I found very few. So I wonder, why so few of them are made into movies.
In IMDB I found that A British science-fiction anthology series "Out of the Unknown" made few episodes with characters from Asimovs robot series.

The Naked Sun (1969)

At 1964 there was The Caves of Steel (TV) (novel)
There have been several movies made from other of his robot stories like
Bicentennial Man (1999) (novel "The Positronic Man") (short story "The Bicentennial Man") aka 200 Jahre Mann, Der (Germany)


And
I, Robot (2004) (suggested by book)


Why there are so few his movies? And there are no movies from Robot, Empire, Foundation series. It might be because of enormous size of his created world. Asimov's universe is largest fictional universe. It's timespan is more than 20 thousand years and it speaks about human colonization of galaxy, creation of galactic empire, it's destruction and beginning of second empire.
1. There must be several movies to tell even part of so huge story, so it is huge project to start.
2. You can't make it cheaply, even first of movies Caves of Steel will require a lot of special effects.
Robot series coud be easier to make than Empire series. It really would be hard to tell empire series story in movies because -
3. It is not just story about a character or person but about civilization, galaxy.

I think that All Robot, Empire, Foundation series could be put in 5 movies. First two about Elijah Baley,
R. Daneel Olivaw and Giskard, but 3rd about Empire and two last about Fundation.




But maybe 4 movies would be better. In Fundation series is a lot of philosophical thoughts and not much action, so all foundation books could fit in two movies.

otrdiena, 2008. gada 29. jūlijs

Fundation movies on screen

Tue Jul 29, 2008 12:45am ED
Reuter
By Steven Zeitchik
The ousted founders of downsized studio New Line Cinema are producing an adaptation of the Isaac Asimov sci-fi epic "Foundation."

The project marks the first undertaking for Bob Shaye and Michael Lynne, who set up their own banner called Unique Features earlier this month after exiting New Line when the ailing studio was absorbed by its bigger corporate sibling Warner Bros. Unique aims to make two or three movies annually, with Warners handling marketing and distribution.

Science fiction is a genre in which the duo and New Line had dabbled, most notably in recent years with "The Last Mimzy," which Shaye directed. That 2007 film grossed just $27 million worldwide, according to tracking firm Box Office Mojo. .................
Each book contains a new set of characters, which poses a multitude of challenges for a big-screen adaptation.

Additionally, Asimov's books tend to incorporate philosophical themes as much as action elements. Still, the very loose adaptation of his "I, Robot" collection of stories turned into a $340 million global hit for Fox in 2004. In 1999, Disney released the Chris Columbus film "Bicentennial Man," based on one of the author's short stories.

ceturtdiena, 2008. gada 26. jūnijs

Are The Three Laws of Robotics Real? Could they be implemented.

Asimov’s Laws of Robotics – Revised Very interesting paper what I found on internet

<
I assume everybody in here knows the Three Laws. Is there anyone who has not seen these? Okay, you can leave! These are really the classics. Any discussion of machine ethics or how to build safe robots for two-thirds of a century now has had to start with these three laws. In fact, people have written PhD theses on them. People, for example, have compared these to the three parts of the tricameral mind as described by Freud. The first law is the superego, the second law is the ego, and the third law is the id. In fact, as Asimov read absolutely everything, I’m almost certain he had read Freud and might have had some of this in the back of his mind when he made them up. The point is that they’ve had a tremendous amount of staying power and have really formed the basis for any discussion of how you make safe robots.
The only problem is that these three laws, as phrased in English, are not really what Asimov had in mind. What he had in mind in the first story he wrote about safe robots was that you build it to be good, and it’s good because you built it that way. ............
To get back to his notion of what the Three Laws were actually like, there is a little byplay in “The Naked Sun” where he has a roboticist explaining the innards of one of the robots that has been just slightly tweaked for special tasks to Lije Bailey, the detective. He says, “If you read that strengthening of the C Integral governing the Sicrokovich tandem route response at the W65 level…” And in the actual book, Bailey says, “Double-talk!” The point is that Asimov’s notion of how the laws were represented were a lot more like circuitry than text. .........
Imagine trying to set down a set of rules for a machine that is going to exist in a situation where it is operating in a world of concepts that you don’t know. You have no idea not only what kind of world it is but the concepts that are going to be used to parse that world are beyond you. You are going to sit down and try to write a law that tells it what to do. It’s going to be like Hamurrabi trying to prevent the Enron scandal. ...........
You’re going to have to build in something that is a lot more abstract. Vague, general principles, tradition, and that sort of thing. You’re going to have to build the machine in such a way that it can continue to exercise the same kind of judgment that you did in extending the rules itself in order to get the effect ultimately that you want, or maybe even that you don’t want.............
What we have to do is to design sets of rules and ways of building our robots and AI’s that we know they will be able to do well in the ecosystem of all the different kinds of minds that will exist tomorrow...........
Law #1: An AI shall understand as much as possible. This actually goes back to something that Peter Voss was saying yesterday. There is a lot of evil that gets done just because people are dumb. .......
Sub-law of #1: A robot should understand memetic evolution. Why should it bother to understand evolution? Evolution is where morals come from in the first place.
http://www.acceleratingfuture.com/people/J-Storrs-Hall